A Think Again Media Group publication
On This Day Quiz

The international bench behind a landmark courtroom

Nuremberg tribunal: the international bench behind the trial

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · On This Day Quiz

Nuremberg tribunal: the international bench behind the trial

The Nuremberg tribunal began its first trial on November 20, 1945, with a bench created by four Allied governments. The United States, United Kingdom, France, and Soviet Union each appointed one judge and one alternate. Their founding charter specified a four-member tribunal and called for alternates to attend its sessions whenever possible. The arrangement placed representatives of the original signatories together in a single court charged with trying major European Axis war criminals.

The legal foundation had been signed in London on August 8, 1945. Its agreement addressed accused war criminals whose offenses had no particular geographical location. That category stood alongside the earlier Allied commitment to return other accused perpetrators to the countries where their crimes had occurred. The agreement incorporated a separate charter defining the international court's constitution, jurisdiction, and functions. It also preserved the authority of national and occupation courts, so the international institution did not absorb every wartime criminal proceeding.

Other governments could join the agreement through diplomatic notice to the United Kingdom, which then informed the signatories and adhering states. The founding text also required the original signatories to make detained defendants available for investigation and trial. Its duration provisions protected proceedings and findings already undertaken if a signatory subsequently withdrew. These clauses supplied an institutional framework beyond the immediate task of assembling prosecutors and judges in a courtroom.

The charter gave the Nuremberg tribunal specific rules for reaching decisions. All four judges, or alternates replacing absent members, constituted the necessary quorum. A president was selected from among the members. Ordinary decisions followed a majority, with the president's vote decisive in an equal division, while convictions and sentences required affirmative votes from at least three members. The charter also provided for a chief prosecutor appointed by each signatory, with the prosecutors acting together on the indictment and allocation of work.

The first morning's transcript records the president identifying the London agreement and charter as the court's authority. He explained that the indictment had been lodged in Berlin on October 18 and that each defendant had possessed a German copy for more than 30 days. All defendants were represented by counsel. Most had chosen their own lawyers; where that had not been possible, the tribunal had selected counsel acceptable to them. The president also referred to prosecution documents being made available to the defense.

The indictment was then read into the public proceedings. Its accusations included a common plan or conspiracy, crimes against peace, war crimes, and crimes against humanity. The prosecution's presentation named individuals and organizations against which it sought findings. The November 20 transcript records the charges as accusations opening a judicial proceeding, before the later presentation of evidence and the eventual judgments. The president stressed the responsibility of the participants and the requirement for order in the courtroom.

The following morning brought an immediate procedural dispute. Defense lawyers said they had been unable to speak with their clients before the session and needed a chance to consult. The president distinguished written communication inside the courtroom from private consultation outside it. After a further request, the tribunal adjourned for 15 minutes so counsel could speak with their clients. The exchange survives in the November 21 transcript, alongside the court's insistence on following its prescribed sequence of proceedings.

After the recess, defendants were called individually to the microphone to enter guilty or not-guilty pleas. The president restricted that stage to the plea itself, reserving fuller defense statements for later. When one defendant began a longer statement, the president interrupted and repeated the requirement. Another defendant's brief negative reply was entered as a not-guilty plea. These recorded exchanges show the Nuremberg tribunal putting its procedural framework into operation through particular rulings during the opening sessions.

The National Archives' administrative history describes the work behind the courtroom presentation. American lawyers and support personnel collaborated with British, French, and Soviet counterparts. Their evidence came partly from interrogations but chiefly from seized German records. Preserved case files included copies of documents, English translations, and staff analyses explaining their significance. The documentary record therefore extended beyond spoken testimony to the collection, translation, and organization of material produced before the proceedings began.

The trial's judgments followed on September 30 and October 1, 1946. The Archives records three acquittals and nineteen convictions, together with findings concerning the accused organizations. It identifies the official English and German editions of the proceedings as 42 volumes each, published in 1947–1949. The Nuremberg tribunal's records belonged to that international proceeding; the later American military tribunals at Nuremberg formed a separate set of cases and records. The four-government bench remained the defining institutional arrangement of the first trial.

The Question

How many Allied governments each appointed a judge and an alternate to the tribunal whose Nuremberg trial began on November 20, 1945?

Show the answer

The Answer

Four governments supplied the judges: the United States, United Kingdom, France, and Soviet Union. The tribunal’s 1945 charter allotted each one a member and an alternate.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to On This Day Quiz’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.