A Think Again Media Group publication
On This Day Quiz

An international assembly with a surprising voting rule

League Assembly: several representatives and a single national vote

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · On This Day Quiz

League Assembly: several representatives and a single national vote

The first League Assembly met in Geneva on November 15, 1920. Its delegations represented an international organization with a striking rule of representation: each member had one vote, although it could send as many as three representatives. Population, territory, and the size of a delegation did not change that formal allocation. The arrangement was set down in the Covenant of the League of Nations, the organization's founding instrument.

The opening followed an earlier institutional beginning. The League's first Council meeting had taken place in Paris on January 16, 1920. Its headquarters moved from London to Geneva on November 1, shortly before the Assembly gathered. The first permanent home was the lakeside building later known as the Palais Wilson. French and English were the organization's official languages. Geneva housed the central administration, while the two political bodies had distinct memberships and schedules. The Assembly represented the whole membership; the Council brought together a smaller group.

The Covenant described the organization as operating through an Assembly and a Council supported by a permanent Secretariat. It allowed the League Assembly to consider any matter within the organization's sphere or affecting world peace. Equal votes in the Assembly coexisted with a different structure in the Council, where the principal Allied and Associated Powers held places alongside representatives of other members chosen by the Assembly. The Covenant also distinguished ordinary decisions from procedure. Agreement of all represented members was the general rule, while procedural business, including the appointment of investigative committees, could be decided by a majority.

The United States remained outside this system. The State Department's Office of the Historian describes an organization created after the First World War to provide a standing forum for international disputes. President Woodrow Wilson promoted it, but his government never became a member. Opposition in the Senate focused on the commitments membership might impose and their consequences for American independence of action. Senator Henry Cabot Lodge led that opposition. In March 1920, a 49–35 vote fell short of the required approval for the treaty and Covenant. The Geneva meeting therefore proceeded without the country whose president had championed the project.

The documentary notes distinguished routes into the organization. China had rejected the Shantung provisions of the peace settlement with Germany, but entered the League by signing and ratifying the treaty with Austria, which took effect on July 16, 1920. Rumania's membership followed ratification of the treaty with Hungary in September 1920. These entries preceded the first Assembly's admission votes later in the autumn. The compilation recorded membership obtained through the peace settlements alongside membership subsequently granted through the Assembly.

Membership itself was part of the League Assembly's work. The State Department's documentary edition of the peace settlement records several admissions during the closing weeks of 1920. Austria entered on December 15. Bulgaria, Finland, Costa Rica, and Luxembourg followed on December 16, and Albania on December 17. The same compilation lists Panama's entry on November 25. These dates show an organization whose membership continued changing during the first session, rather than a closed gathering consisting only of the states present at its beginning.

Luxembourg's application exposed a complication behind the admission votes. The Grand Duchy had applied by letter on February 23, 1920, expressing a strong wish to retain its neutrality. The League Assembly referred the application to its Fifth Committee, which heard the head of Luxembourg's government. A further letter from its delegates on November 28 confirmed acceptance of the Covenant's obligations without reservations, including its sanctions obligations. The committee recommended admission on the understanding that Luxembourg would bring its laws into harmony with the resulting obligations. On December 16, the Assembly recorded 38 votes in favor, none against, and four abstentions or absences.

The admission was followed by correspondence in 1921 about Luxembourg's position. The Council's response, approved on June 21, described membership as final and absolute. The government's revision of its constitution and legislation did not create a provisional category of membership in the meantime. Its rights and obligations followed from entry itself. That exchange placed a specific diplomatic difficulty beside the Covenant's formal categories: an applicant's earlier status had to be reconciled with the obligations attached to becoming a member. The documentary record preserved both the admission tally and the subsequent clarification.

The American absence did not mean complete separation from the League's activities. The Office of the Historian records that the Harding, Coolidge, and Hoover administrations associated the United States with League efforts on several issues, within the limits Congress permitted. Suspicion that cooperation might become membership restricted a closer relationship.

The Question

Under the League of Nations Covenant, how many votes did each member have in the Assembly?

Show the answer

The Answer

One vote. The Covenant allowed each member up to three representatives while assigning it a single vote.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to On This Day Quiz’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.