A Think Again Media Group publication
On This Day Quiz

The November patent behind a glass radio component

Fleming valve: a patent, a receiving instrument, and its surviving originals

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · On This Day Quiz

Fleming valve: a patent, a receiving instrument, and its surviving originals

The Fleming valve entered the British patent record through an application filed on November 16, 1904. John Ambrose Fleming described an instrument for detecting and measuring alternating electrical currents, especially the high-frequency oscillations used in wireless telegraphy. Its essential task was rectification: the instrument produced current in one direction from an alternating input. The British document, numbered 24,850, described a hot conductor and a cold conductor inside a vessel from which air had been removed.

The filing date and the published patent date belonged to different stages. The British application was published on September 21, 1905, as GB190424850A. Its title concerned instruments for detecting and measuring alternating currents. A related United States patent appeared on November 7, 1905, under the more explicit title Instrument for Converting Alternating Electric Currents into Continuous Currents. That document, U.S. patent 803,684, named Fleming of London as inventor and the Marconi Wireless Telegraph Company of America as assignee.

The American specification explained why the conversion mattered for measurement. Ordinary direct-current instruments did not respond to the alternating currents Fleming wanted to detect. The specification named a mirror galvanometer among the instruments intended to register the converted current. His device was described as an electric valve because electrical passage through its evacuated space was unequal in the two directions. The specification illustrated an application to wireless telegraphy and discussed other alternating-current sources as well. It described instruments with one bulb, a paired arrangement, and multiple valves operating together. Those variations concerned the electrical indication produced from the received oscillations, rather than the generation of a radio transmission.

The Fleming valve grew out of investigations of incandescent lamps. A 1939 notice in Nature recorded Fleming's retrospective account at University College London on April 27. He described studying a narrow line of clearer glass within the carbon deposit left inside older lamps. He interpreted it as a shadow produced when particles driven from one part of a filament were blocked by another part of its loop. That was an account of his earlier reasoning, delivered decades after the lamp observations and the 1904 patent application.

The occasion itself concerned surviving instruments. R. McV. Weston had presented an exhibition case for early valves held by the college's electrical engineering department. The collection included examples given by Weston and Fleming. Nature reported that the unveiling involved a torch, photocell, valve amplifier, and relay, after which Fleming spoke about the history of the objects. By then he had held the college's electrical engineering chair for more than 40 years. The display placed the early glass devices within the institution where he had worked, while his address supplied a personal recollection of their development.

The American patent's later legal history followed a separate course. In Marconi Wireless Telegraph Co. of America v. United States, decided on June 21, 1943, the U.S. Supreme Court considered Fleming's patent alongside other wireless patents. The litigation concerned a company claim for compensation for government infringement. For the Fleming patent, the Court examined the breadth of the original claims and a disclaimer filed on November 17, 1915. That disclaimer had narrowed a claim originally covering low-frequency as well as high-frequency currents to the high-frequency oscillations associated with wireless transmission.

The Court upheld the conclusion that the Fleming patent was invalid. It found that the excessive claim had not been made inadvertently and that the delay before the disclaimer was unreasonable. The opinion referred to Fleming's own earlier publications when assessing what had already been known. Its ruling concerned the scope and history of the patent claims, including the unsuccessful attempt to narrow them. The existence of a functioning rectifying device and the legal standing of the American patent were therefore distinct matters in the record. The Court affirmed the judgment challenged by the company in that part of the case.

Fleming's work had extended beyond the Fleming valve. Nature's 1949 centenary notice identified him as scientific adviser to the Marconi company from 1899 and as designer of the powerful transmitting station involved in the December 1901 transatlantic signals. The notice nevertheless described his 1904 oscillation valve as the invention best known to the public.

The centenary also brought the Fleming valve into another institutional display. The Science Museum in South Kensington exhibited his original valve for two weeks beginning on November 29, 1949. Lamps and valves used in his early investigations accompanied it. The exhibition commemorated the hundredth anniversary of his birth on November 29, 1849. Fleming had died in 1945, four years before the centenary display.

The Question

In Fleming's November 16, 1904 British patent application, what did his valve do to alternating currents?

Show the answer

The Answer

It rectified them, producing current in one direction. Fleming described a device for detecting and measuring alternating currents, particularly the high-frequency oscillations used in wireless telegraphy.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to On This Day Quiz’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.