Benny Goodman: rehearsals, solos and the Carnegie Hall recording
Benny Goodman brought his band to Carnegie Hall on January 16, 1938, with guests from the Count Basie and Duke Ellington orchestras. The concert sold out weeks ahead, with the best seats priced at $2.75. A clarinetist associated with swing dance music was presenting a formal concert, joining his regular musicians with visiting performers for several different kinds of musical collaboration.
The hall already had a history of African American music. James Reese Europe and his Clef Club Orchestra had presented their Concert of Negro Music there in 1912, bringing ragtime and blues before an integrated audience.
Trumpeter Chris Griffin recalled the preparations in an interview recorded for American Masters on January 25, 1993. Goodman rehearsed the musicians inside the hall so they could adjust to its lively acoustics. Griffin remembered roughly a week of rehearsals and the added presence of players from the Ellington and Basie bands. His recollection also retained the anxiety of waiting to walk onstage. Rehearsing familiar music in an unfamiliar room was part of the job. The building's reputation could still make experienced performers nervous, even after they had spent time learning how their instruments sounded inside it.
Singer Martha Tilton's recorded recollections supply the working schedule behind the polish. Speaking to American Masters on March 12, 1993, she described six nights a week at the Manhattan Room of the Pennsylvania Hotel. Sundays meant traveling to another city, performing there, and returning for Monday. A weekly radio program took up another whole day or more. She remembered continuing to sing through bad colds and eventually spending a two-week vacation sleeping on a beach at Cape May. Carnegie Hall stood beside a demanding routine of hotel appearances, broadcasts and travel, rather than a leisurely succession of prestigious engagements.
The program gave that working band several different tasks. Alongside its regular repertoire came a historical section called Twenty Years of Jazz and an extended jam session with visiting musicians. Harry James supplied trumpet, Lionel Hampton vibraphone and Gene Krupa drums. Goodman was the headliner, yet the varied personnel and formats spread musical responsibility across the stage. A historical demonstration, a guest session and the band's established numbers shared the same evening.
Pianist Jess Stacy remembered the audience at unusually close quarters. In his January 28, 1993, American Masters interview, he described people seated onstage so near the piano that moving his arms could mean bumping somebody in the ribs. He also remembered having a fine concert grand to play. Those details place the performance at the keyboard: a good instrument, cramped physical space and a crowded room. The pianist's surroundings were considerably more practical than the grand language later attached to the concert. Even a celebrated musical occasion left somebody trying to find enough elbow room.
Griffin also recalled Krupa's drumming during Sing, Sing, Sing. He recalled the drummer finding a beat that changed the band's feel and gave a frequently performed number new life. Griffin distinguished that evening's playing from Krupa's usual showmanship: he thought the drummer was supporting and integrating with the ensemble particularly well. This was a colleague's judgment, offered decades afterward. It locates the excitement in interaction among performers, with the drums changing what the other musicians could do, rather than in the prestige of the address alone.
Stacy supplied his own explanation of the piano feature in Sing, Sing, Sing. He thought Benny Goodman liked the accompaniment he was playing behind the clarinet solo and signaled for him to continue as a soloist. The cue grew out of what Goodman had just heard. Stacy's memory gives that celebrated passage a specific beginning: accompaniment caught the bandleader's attention, and space opened for the pianist. In an evening prepared through repeated rehearsals, a musician could still receive an opportunity in the middle of a performance. Preparation and an unexpected solo occupied the same stage.
Tilton remembered a similarly persistent attention to the instrument away from the stage. During bus journeys, Benny Goodman traveled with the musicians and tried out clarinet reeds while others wanted to sleep. She recalled long days on the road, sometimes followed by changing for a performance in a cold ladies' room when there was no hotel stop. The glamorous bandstand had a less glamorous route to it.
The performance acquired another audience through records. TIME's December 4, 1950, notice reported Columbia's release of The Famous 1938 Carnegie Hall Jazz Concert on four LP sides. The recording therefore reached shops nearly 13 years after the concert. Discussing the stored acetate discs, Benny Goodman said, "I put them away so carefully I couldn't find them." That contemporary release notice fixes a second date in the performance's history: the concert happened in 1938, while its arrival as a commercially issued album belonged to 1950.
- WNET/PBS American Masters, Chris Griffin: recorded interview, January 25, 1993 — www.pbs.org
- WNET/PBS American Masters, Jess Stacy: recorded interview, January 28, 1993 — www.pbs.org
- WNET/PBS American Masters, Martha Tilton: recorded interview, March 12, 1993 — www.pbs.org
- TIME, Music: A Different Era, December 4, 1950: contemporary Columbia release notice — time.com
- HISTORY, Benny Goodman brings jazz to Carnegie Hall: program and earlier Clef Club concert — www.history.com