West Side Story: the musical taking shape in notes and rehearsals
West Side Story opened at Broadway's Winter Garden Theatre on September 26, 1957. The production credits divide its creation among several people: Leonard Bernstein composed the music, Stephen Sondheim supplied the lyrics, Arthur Laurents wrote the book, and Jerome Robbins conceived, directed, and choreographed it. Larry Kert played Tony, Carol Lawrence played Maria, and Chita Rivera played Anita. The surviving working papers make that collaboration tangible. Annotated Shakespeare, choreographic notes, musical sketches, and private letters preserve decisions made before the familiar title reached the marquee.
Bernstein's copy of Romeo and Juliet contains traces of an earlier design. The first adaptation would have replaced Shakespeare's feuding families with Jewish and Catholic families. Notes inside the book consider opening at a Mulberry Street festival or during Easter and Passover. A scene breakdown from around 1949 still uses names such as Romeo, Juliet, Tybalt, and Mercutio. These documents preserve a stage in development, rather than a description of the eventual Broadway production. West Side Story's final identities and setting emerged through substantial changes to the original proposal.
A six-page synopsis by Laurents, dated October 1955, already describes moments that came close to their final form, including the lovers' first meeting. Robbins's response discusses the division into two acts, Anita's characterization, casting, and dance. The early documents therefore contain more than the premise of updating Shakespeare. They register practical decisions about the shape of an evening in the theater, the weight given to particular characters, and the relationship between spoken action and movement. Adaptation required choices at the level of scenes as well as plot.
The papers for West Side Story's rumble show how closely music and choreography developed together. Robbins's notes include a rough set design, while Bernstein labels part of a musical sketch cat-play. The Library of Congress cautiously connects that label with Robbins's description. The music contains passages in which phrases echo one another, along with instructions for wood block, cymbal, and tenor drum. These are working materials for a staged encounter. Rhythm, movement, and the physical space of the fight were being considered in the same creative process.
Oliver Smith's finished rumble backdrop depicts the underside of the Manhattan Bridge viewed from Brooklyn, with a threatening sky. An arched overpass also appears in Robbins's notes. The contrasting Somewhere sequence survives in descriptions, dance notes, and a neatly copied piano-vocal score. Bernstein's copy includes an optional second voice in counterpoint and a fuller accompaniment than the production ultimately used. West Side Story's manuscripts thus preserve possibilities that the finished show narrowed. A surviving score can contain an abandoned choice as well as the musical material that reached performance.
Bernstein's letters to his wife, Felicia, record a less orderly emotional process. She was visiting her family in Santiago, Chile, while he followed the show through its final weeks of rehearsal and its out-of-town opening in Washington. The Library of Congress describes the letters as ranging from frustration and agony to euphoria. The displayed letters begin on July 19 and end on August 23, 1957. Their dates give the rehearsal period a shape, while the changing emotional tones record how the composer experienced a work still being prepared for audiences.
The letters also place West Side Story among Bernstein's other commitments. He writes about signing a conducting contract with the New York Philharmonic and about an approaching 39th birthday. He writes, too, about how much he misses Felicia and their children, Jamie and Alexander. These personal details keep the correspondence from becoming only a production chronicle. The musical's development occupied part of a life in which professional decisions and family separation continued together. Rehearsal notes describe work to be done; the letters add the composer's shifting response to doing it.
The commercial production also had a precise public record. Robert E. Griffith and Harold S. Prince produced it by arrangement with Roger L. Stevens, and Max Goberman was musical director. The original Broadway engagement eventually ran for 732 performances, closing on June 27, 1959. The engagement moved to the Broadway Theatre on March 2, 1959, and returned to the Winter Garden on May 11. Its venue history records one production continuing across a change of address before reaching the end of its original run.
The Library's exhibition also preserves Carol Lawrence's ballet slippers from the Somewhere ballet. In her recollection, Robbins had first chosen dancers from the American Ballet Theatre to portray Tony and Maria in the ballet. Lawrence asked whether she and Larry Kert could learn the steps and perform their own roles, and Robbins eventually agreed. She also recalled asking for a low curved heel to help her balance. The shoes and her account connect the finished production to an actor's practical choices about movement. Alongside the sketches and letters, they preserve decisions made by the people who had to bring West Side Story to the stage.
- Internet Broadway Database, West Side Story, original production: dates, credits, cast, and 732 performances — www.ibdb.com
- Library of Congress, Birth of a Musical: annotated Shakespeare, scene breakdowns, and Laurents–Robbins development documents — loc.gov
- Library of Congress, On The Rumble and Somewhere: choreographic notes, musical manuscripts, and Oliver Smith designs — loc.gov
- Library of Congress, Letters from Bernstein: July–August 1957 correspondence with Felicia and collection descriptions — loc.gov
- Library of Congress, The Legacy of West Side Story: Carol Lawrence’s ballet slippers and her account of performing the ballet — loc.gov