A Think Again Media Group publication
On This Day Quiz

The presidential rematch with an unusual result

The 1892 election: a return to the presidency after four years away

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · On This Day Quiz

The 1892 election: a return to the presidency after four years away

The 1892 election returned Grover Cleveland to the presidency after an interval occupied by Benjamin Harrison. Election Day fell on November 8. Cleveland had already held the office following his victory in 1884, then lost his bid for another term in 1888. His second inauguration came on March 4, 1893.

Historian Henry F. Graff describes Cleveland's earlier electoral appeal as a combination of administrative reform and opposition to political corruption. His battles with New York City's Tammany Hall attracted support across party lines. In 1884, reform-minded Republicans known as Mugwumps disliked their own nominee, James G. Blaine, and supported Cleveland. New York was crucial: Cleveland's narrow advantage there helped deliver his first presidential victory. In 1888, tariff policy became a central division. Republicans defended protective tariffs, while Cleveland emphasized tariff reduction and civil service reform.

The 1888 electoral count recorded the defeat that made the later return possible. Harrison received 233 electoral votes and Cleveland 168, out of 401. The required majority was 201. New York supplied Harrison with 36 votes, while Indiana supplied another 15. Illinois contributed 22 to Harrison, and Pennsylvania 30. Cleveland's column included New Jersey's 9 votes and Connecticut's 6, alongside the votes of numerous Southern states. The vice-presidential count followed the same division: Levi P. Morton received 233 votes and Allen G. Thurman 168. Harrison therefore took office with Morton, while Cleveland and Thurman lost the electoral contest.

Four years later, Democrats assembled in Chicago from June 21 to June 23. Cleveland secured their presidential nomination on the first ballot on June 23, with Adlai Stevenson as the vice-presidential candidate. Cleveland received formal notification in July and issued his acceptance letter in September. The 1892 election thus placed a former Democratic president against the Republican who had displaced him, with a different running mate accompanying Cleveland's renewed candidacy.

Cleveland's acceptance letter, dated September 26, set out his own account of the campaign's economic dispute. He described tariffs as a form of federal taxation that reduced the earnings available to ordinary Americans. He argued that their legitimate purpose was to finance government, rather than confer advantages on selected private enterprises. His proposed readjustment included freer access to raw materials for manufacturers. He also denied that tariff reform meant an abrupt abandonment of all import duties. These were the candidate's stated positions, expressed before the ballots were cast.

The same letter connected economic policy with administration. Cleveland favored a currency whose different forms maintained equal purchasing power, whether represented by gold, silver, or paper. He associated civil service reform with appointments based on demonstrated fitness. In his description, public employment belonged within an efficient administration rather than a distribution of rewards for party loyalty. The letter presented tariff policy, monetary stability, and government appointments as related matters of public trust.

The contest also included a substantial third-party challenge. Graff identifies James B. Weaver of Iowa as the nominee of the People's Party, also called the Populist Party. Its support brought together western populists and southern Farmers' Alliance supporters. Cleveland received about 46 percent of the popular vote, Harrison about 43 percent, and Weaver more than 8 percent. Cleveland's victory therefore came with a plurality of the national popular vote. Democrats also regained control of both houses of Congress. In 1888 the popular count had also favored Cleveland: Graff gives him 48.6 percent against Harrison's 47.9 percent. That earlier popular advantage had not delivered the presidency.

The final 1892 election tally gave Cleveland 277 electoral votes, Harrison 145, and Weaver 22. With 444 votes available, the majority threshold was 223. Stevenson received the same 277 votes as Cleveland. Republican vice-presidential nominee Whitelaw Reid received 145, while Weaver's running mate, James G. Field, received 22. New York and Indiana, which had supported Harrison in the earlier count, now supplied Cleveland with 36 and 15 electoral votes respectively.

Several states divided their electoral votes. California gave Cleveland 8 and Harrison 1. Michigan gave Cleveland 5 and Harrison 9. North Dakota's three votes were divided equally among Cleveland, Harrison, and Weaver. Weaver received all of Colorado's 4 votes, Idaho's 3, Kansas's 10, and Nevada's 3, as well as one vote from Oregon. The result combined Cleveland's return in pivotal states with a western challenge that secured its own place in the electoral count.

After the 1892 election, monetary anxiety accompanied the transition between administrations. The American Presidency Project's chronology records growing concern about abandonment of the gold standard in February 1893. When Cleveland took office, his administration found only about $101 million in Treasury gold, alongside approximately $25 million in other currency.

The Question

Who defeated Benjamin Harrison in the U.S. presidential election held on November 8, 1892?

Show the answer

The Answer

Grover Cleveland defeated Harrison and returned to the presidency. The electoral count was 277 for Cleveland, 145 for Harrison, and 22 for James B. Weaver.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to On This Day Quiz’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.