A Think Again Media Group publication
On This Day Quiz

Two patents, two different partners

Ritty cash register: the changing names on two patents

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · On This Day Quiz

Ritty cash register: the changing names on two patents

The Ritty cash register patent issued on November 4, 1879, named two inventors: James Ritty and John Ritty of Dayton, Ohio. Their application had been filed on March 26. Numbered 221,360, the document described an improvement in a cash register and indicator.

James Ritty's occupation helps explain the commercial setting. The Library of Congress identifies him as an Ohio saloonkeeper concerned that employees were retaining money from customer purchases. The proposed machine addressed the recording of sales. It belonged to a business in which payments passed through employees' hands, and the amount received had to be established separately from anyone's recollection. The library's history places this concern at the center of the November 1879 patent, rather than presenting the invention as an abstract exercise in arithmetic.

The 1879 specification separated the amount of an individual payment from the accumulated total. Its enclosed case contained an index dial, an indicator, and numbered disks visible through openings. The illustrated arrangement included 20 keys with buttons in two banks. The inventors explained that the two rows kept the machine's width manageable. A bell or other sounding device was another specified component. These descriptions establish that the Ritty cash register was already conceived as a combination of a visible indication, an internal total, and an audible signal, all within a single mechanical instrument.

Later biographical accounts describe Ritty seeing a device that counted the revolutions of a ship's propeller during an Atlantic journey in 1878. It associates his subsequent experiments with his brother John's mechanical skills. The brothers developed several prototypes and opened a small Dayton factory while James continued operating his saloon. Early models lacked both a cash drawer and a receipt printer. Those limitations distinguish the first machines from the elaborate counter fixtures associated with later cash-register manufacture.

Commercial success did not immediately follow. James sold his interests in the cash-register business in 1881. The Library of Congress describes a group of investors establishing the National Manufacturing Company, followed by ownership under John Henry Patterson and Frank Jefferson Patterson and the name National Cash Register Company. Later additions included a paper roll and eventually an electric motor.

The second patent makes another stage unusually explicit. Patent 271,363, issued on January 30, 1883, named James Ritty and John Birch, both of Dayton. Its specification recorded an application filed on February 15, 1882, and identified the inventors as assignors to Jacob H. Eckert of Cincinnati. Thus Birch and Eckert occupied different positions in the document: one shared the invention credit, while the other appeared as its assignee. John Ritty's place on the 1879 patent did not carry over into this later pairing.

The 1883 specification for the Ritty cash register emphasized numbered tablets visible to customers, alongside the register’s accumulated record. It described a displayed value remaining visible until another tablet replaced it. Its drawings included the bell mechanism, the indicating tablets, and the registering disks. A metal framework stood within an outer case whose decoration could vary. The specification therefore devoted attention to both the public-facing display and the concealed mechanical components. It connected those components within a stated arrangement, rather than claiming the general idea of counting money in any possible machine.

The later Ritty cash register patent reached the U.S. Supreme Court in National Cash Register Company v. Boston Cash Indicator and Recorder Company. Decided on March 4, 1895, the case concerned alleged infringement of the 1883 Ritty and Birch patent. The lower federal court had dismissed the complaint, and National Cash Register appealed. Justice Brown delivered the opinion. The appeal came from the federal circuit court in Massachusetts and was argued on January 17, 1895. Only the first claim was alleged to have been infringed; the recording mechanism elsewhere in the patent was outside that dispute. Earlier indicating-machine patents entered the comparison as evidence of designs already known before Ritty and Birch’s invention. The opinion distinguished the particular combination under review from those preceding arrangements, then considered the Boston company’s design. The disputed claim concerned the indicating mechanism, including the support that held a tablet in view. The justices compared a pivoted wing in the patented arrangement with a sliding bar in the defendant's machine. They concluded that the infringement charge was established, reversed the lower decree, and returned the case for further proceedings.

James's saloon career continued while the Ritty cash register passed into this industrial and judicial history. He opened the Pony House in 1882 and commissioned a large mahogany bar from woodcarvers associated with the Barney and Smith Car Company. The bar carried his initials, JR. He retired from the saloon business in 1895, the same year the Supreme Court decided the dispute concerning the later patent.

The Question

Who shared James Ritty’s U.S. patent 221,360, issued on November 4, 1879?

Show the answer

The Answer

John Ritty shared the 1879 patent with James Ritty. The patent names both men of Dayton, Ohio; John Birch appears with James on the separate 1883 patent.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to On This Day Quiz’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.