O.K. Corral gunfight: thirty seconds examined under oath
The O.K. Corral gunfight lasted about thirty seconds. Sheriff John Behan gave an even more cautious estimate under cross-examination: he did not think the interval between the first and last shots exceeded 20 or 30 seconds. The shooting in Tombstone on October 26, 1881, killed Thomas and Frank McLaury and William Clanton. Its brevity contrasts with the surviving testimony, where witnesses spent far longer describing an approaching group, the position of a pistol, or a movement toward a coat.
The immediate dispute involved carrying weapons inside town. Tombstone's Ordinance No. 9, effective April 19, 1881, prohibited carrying a deadly weapon in the hand or on the person without written permission. It covered firearms, bowie knives, and dirks. An exception allowed people entering or leaving town to carry weapons while proceeding in good faith, within a reasonable time, to deposit or retrieve them. The legal setting of the O.K. Corral gunfight therefore involved the purpose and circumstances of carrying arms, as well as their mere presence.
Another provision required policemen to arrest people brawling or quarreling in public streets, or committing disorderly acts that might occasion a breach of the peace. The ordinances imposed duties, but their wording alone cannot establish whether a particular shooting was justified. In the preliminary hearing after the O.K. Corral gunfight, Magistrate Wells Spicer had to consider the encounter itself. He distinguished the officers' authority to approach and disarm armed men from the circumstances under which they could lawfully fire.
Virgil Earp testified that he called on Wyatt and Morgan Earp and Doc Holliday to help disarm the Clantons and McLaurys. He described turning west onto Fremont Street toward Fly's lodging house and finding the men in a vacant lot between the photography gallery and the building beside it. That places the O.K. Corral gunfight in a confined space associated with the corral, rather than inside a broad livestock enclosure. Virgil also explained an exchange of objects before the approach: Holliday took his shotgun, while he took Holliday's walking stick.
Behan described trying to disarm the group himself. He said Frank McLaury initially refused to surrender his pistol, while Ike Clanton said he had none. Behan put an arm around Ike's waist to check. Tom McLaury opened his coat to show that he was unarmed. Under cross-examination, however, Behan acknowledged that Tom might have carried a pistol without his knowing it. The distinction is small but consequential: an inspection and a gesture supplied evidence of what the sheriff could see, rather than certainty about everything concealed.
The two officials sharply disagreed about their meeting before the O.K. Corral gunfight. Virgil said Behan warned that the men would murder him, then said he had disarmed them. Virgil recalled moving his own pistol farther around his waist after hearing that assurance. Behan denied telling the approaching party that everyone had been disarmed. He instead described attempting to stop the Earps and Holliday, who brushed past him. These incompatible statements concern the information available immediately before the confrontation, when a mistaken belief about weapons could affect the next movement.
Behan said a demand to raise hands was followed almost immediately by shots from the Earp party. He focused on a nickel-plated pistol and identified it as the first weapon fired, while qualifying his identification of its holder. Virgil testified that Billy Clanton and Frank McLaury drew and cocked their revolvers after his demand for their arms. He described two shots sounding together and believed one came from Billy. The O.K. Corral gunfight generated competing descriptions of nearly simultaneous actions, with each witness's attention directed toward particular people and weapons.
Spicer's decision of November 30 did not simply praise every earlier choice by the officers. He criticized Virgil's recruitment of Wyatt and Holliday because of their recent personal disputes with the other men. Yet he found no criminality in that decision under the circumstances. On the shooting, he acknowledged credible testimony on both sides of the surrender dispute, then gave weight to witnesses positioned at a distance and to the wounds described in evidence. His reasoning favored the defense, but the document retains the conflicts he had to weigh.
The ruling ended a preliminary examination, rather than a jury trial. Spicer concluded that the evidence would not warrant conviction and ordered Wyatt Earp and Holliday released. He expressly recognized that the sitting grand jury could disregard his findings and seek an indictment. That procedural boundary is part of the O.K. Corral gunfight's history. About half a minute of shooting led to weeks of legal scrutiny, and the surviving record preserves both a decision and the sharply different observations from which it emerged.
- Sheriff John H. Behan, testimony of November 13–14, 1881, Earp-Holliday preliminary hearing, Famous Trials — www.famous-trials.com
- The Law in Tombstone: Ordinance No. 9 and Ordinance No. 7, 1881, reproduced by Famous Trials — www.famous-trials.com
- Virgil W. Earp, preliminary-hearing testimony, November 1881, Famous Trials — www.famous-trials.com
- Wells Spicer, Decision after the Preliminary Hearing in the Earp-Holliday Case, November 30, 1881, Famous Trials — www.famous-trials.com
- Wikipedia, Gunfight at the O.K. Corral: corroboration of the unchanged answer’s approximate shot count and location — en.wikipedia.org