A Think Again Media Group publication
On This Day Quiz

Who was born in Torun in 1473 and moved the universe?

Copernicus and Earth's motion: the argument inside the 1543 edition

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · On This Day Quiz

Copernicus and Earth's motion: the argument inside the 1543 edition

Earth's motion was the unsettling proposal at the heart of Nicolaus Copernicus' De revolutionibus, published in 1543. The astronomer born in Torun on February 19, 1473, assigned Earth both a daily rotation and an annual circuit around the Sun. His printed argument concerned the position of the observer as much as the positions of the planets. In the dedication to Pope Paul III, he defended a connected arrangement of the heavens against astronomical methods that could calculate individual appearances without producing a consistent whole.

Copernicus began Book I with a spherical universe and a spherical Earth. For Earth's shape, he offered observations of the sky and the horizon. The northern celestial pole appeared higher to someone traveling north, while stars visible farther south disappeared from northern skies. Canopus was visible in Egypt but absent from Italy. A person higher in a ship's rigging could see land concealed from someone on deck. Mountains and valleys interrupted the surface without changing its general form. Earth's motion followed a separate argument: accepting a round Earth did not, by itself, establish that it moved.

The daily appearance of the sky could arise from movement of the objects observed, movement of the observer, or both. Copernicus pointed out that identical movement in the same direction would produce no apparent relative movement. He proposed transferring the daily revolution from the heavens to Earth, rotating west to east. A quiet voyage supplied his comparison. From a ship, the surrounding shore seemed to retreat while the vessel appeared stationary to those aboard. The visible appearance could remain familiar even when its physical explanation changed.

Earth's motion also required a response to objections about the behavior of terrestrial objects. Copernicus considered the fear that rotation would tear Earth apart and turned it toward the traditional moving heavens: the much larger sky would have to travel correspondingly faster. He treated Earth's rotation as natural to its spherical form. He also proposed that nearby air, clouds and other things connected with Earth shared its motion. His discussion addressed why a rotating world could still seem settled to its inhabitants, using arguments about natural movement and the atmosphere.

Planetary distances supplied another problem. Copernicus observed that planets appeared alternately nearer to and farther from Earth. He explicitly recognized that this alone did not determine whether Earth approached and receded from them or they approached and receded from Earth. That distinction limited what a single appearance could establish. The proposed relocation of Earth belonged within a larger arrangement of planetary movements. In his dedication, he argued that the relative positions, orbital dimensions and observed appearances became mutually connected when the movements assigned to Earth were included.

His dissatisfaction was with inconsistency as well as complexity. Some astronomers used concentric circles, others eccentric circles and epicycles, but Copernicus believed that their procedures failed to preserve common starting principles. He compared the result to assembling handsome body parts that did not fit together into one proportionate body. Earth's motion offered a way to seek a coherent system. He planned Book I as the general arrangement of the orbits and the terrestrial movements; the remaining books would develop the movements of the other heavenly bodies alongside Earth's.

Copernicus also named earlier thinkers who had entertained terrestrial motion. Through Cicero and Plutarch, he encountered alternatives to a stationary Earth, including rotation around its own center. He used these precedents as permission to investigate, rather than presenting himself as the first person ever to imagine a moving world. His circular mechanisms likewise belonged to the mathematical traditions he was revising. The change involved which bodies moved and how their movements related, while the dedication still treated uniform motion as a principle worth preserving.

Publication was delayed, but Copernicus' dedication gives specific reasons and specific encouragement. He anticipated contempt for the novelty and apparent absurdity of Earth's motion. Cardinal Nicolaus Schonberg and Tiedemann Giese, Bishop of Culm, urged him to publish. Copernicus credited Giese with repeated encouragement after years of hesitation. Addressing the Pope was itself part of his appeal for protection and recognition of mathematical learning. This mixture of anxiety and support appears in his own prefatory words, alongside the mathematical objections that had prompted his investigation.

The physical edition added a further complication. The Library of Congress identifies its first edition as printed by Johannes Petreius in Nuremberg in 1543. Later scholarship identifies an anonymous foreword as the work of Andreas Osiander, who took over editorial duties after Georg Joachim Rheticus left for Leipzig. Osiander maintained that useful astronomical hypotheses need not be true or even probable. That position differed from Copernicus' commitment to a real moving Earth. Linda Hall Library's history describes an early annotation naming Osiander in a surviving copy, and reproduces another annotated copy from Glasgow.

The Question

On February 19, 1473, a boy was born in Torun, a city on the Vistula River in north-central Poland. He grew up to argue that Earth and the other planets circle the sun. Who was he?

Show the answer

The Answer

Nicolaus Copernicus. Born that day in Torun, he became the father of modern astronomy — the first modern European scientist to propose that Earth and the other planets revolve around the sun. A rather large change of address.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to On This Day Quiz’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.